An AI Law Firm Just Insured Its AI Agents — What That Means for Consultants Who Use AI

What happened. On 7 November 2026 the New York Times reported that Crosby, a New York AI-native law firm, reportedly arranged malpractice cover for its AI agents — the software that does most of its contract review. Founder and CEO Ryan Daniels announced plans to secure the cover on LinkedIn in late July 2026. Crosby employs 45–60 licensed attorneys who review every AI output, and its contract volume grew from $30 million to $1 billion in under a year. The firm says it is working with auditors, bar associations, state regulators and insurers to build evaluation standards and policy terms. Important caveats: the full policy terms have not been published, and regulators have not signed off on standards for insuring AI agents. The New York Times reported on 7 November 2026 that the cover is a $5 million A.I. liability policy placed with Testudo, a Lloyd’s-backed insurer, and that it went into effect that week, after which Crosby removed lawyer supervision for around 20 percent of its gray-area tasks. Some earlier reports described it as a plan to secure cover rather than a bound policy.

Update — 11 November 2026. Cowbell has now launched a standalone AI liability policy for US small businesses using AI agents, available from 1 January 2027 through wholesale brokers. Read our follow-up: Cowbell Launches Standalone AI Liability Insurance for Small Businesses Using AI Agents.

Why it matters beyond law firms. Consultants, IT consultants, marketers and accountants now let AI draft client deliverables too — proposals, code, copy, reports. When AI output contains an error, the client claims against the professional, not the tool vendor, in most engagements. Crosby’s answer was to insure the output, with human review on every piece of work. That is the model consultants should copy: AI drafts, a human checks, insurance covers the gap if something still slips through.

What professional liability / E&O normally covers — and the AI question to ask. A standard policy covers claims that a professional service was negligent or contained an error or omission. It does not automatically answer whether AI-generated work counts the same way, or whether failing to disclose AI use affects a claim. Before relying on a policy, check: (1) does the wording cover work produced with AI tools; (2) is AI use disclosed in client contracts; (3) is there a documented human-review step; (4) are prompts and outputs kept on file; (5) do the limits fit the size of the client engagements.

A short checklist for consultants using AI. Disclose AI use in the engagement letter. Keep a human review step and record it. Keep copies of what the AI produced and what changed. Check the policy’s retroactive date and limits against your largest client. If the current policy is silent on AI, ask the insurer in writing before renewing.

Costs. Professional liability typically runs about $25–$109/month for the professions we track (see the Small Business Insurance Cost Index 2026). The exact price depends on profession, revenue, limits and claims history.

This website contains affiliate links. If you click and request a quote, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Insurance availability and pricing depend on your business type, location, and underwriting approval.

This post is general information about insurance, not legal advice. For advice about your specific situation, speak to a licensed insurance professional or attorney.

Also read: AMA Says AI Can’t Be Licensed as a Physician — and Vendors Should Carry the Liability

Leave a Comment