Contractor Paid $9,297 for Workers’ Comp. Investigators Say He Hid Nearly $1 Million in Payroll

A Miami construction company owner paid $9,297.43 for a year of workers’ compensation insurance. Investigators say the real premium should have been $109,863.

Israel Carballo, owner of Carballo Group LLC, was arrested on 5 November 2026 by the Florida Department of Financial Services’ Criminal Investigations Division. The arrest was announced on 10 November by Florida Chief Financial Officer Blaise Ingoglia. Carballo is charged with grand theft, organised scheme to defraud, and workers’ compensation fraud. He has pleaded not guilty, has been released on bond, and is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Prosecution falls under the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office.

According to investigators, the numbers tell the story. In 2023, Carballo bought workers’ comp cover from NorGuard, a Berkshire Hathaway company, claiming a relatively small workforce — which kept the premium at about $9,300 for the policy year. But subpoenaed subcontractor records showed the company had actually paid workers some $1,074,000, and investigators identified $968,278.71 in unreported payroll exposure. The investigation also found $1,074,278.71 in checks cashed through money service businesses, which investigators say was used to conceal payroll from the insurer.

The alleged result: $100,565.57 in lost premiums. Carballo Group LLC was registered in 2023 and dissolved in 2025 after failing to file an annual report.

It is a stark example of a fraud type that quietly costs honest contractors money — because when premiums go unpaid, everyone else’s rates carry the load.

How workers’ comp premiums actually work

Workers’ compensation premiums are not a flat fee. They are calculated from your payroll, the type of work your employees do, and your claims history. More payroll — especially in high-risk construction classifications — means a higher premium, because the insurer is covering more workers doing dangerous work.

That is why payroll is the number that matters. Under-report it, and the premium drops. The insurer, meanwhile, is unknowingly covering a much bigger workforce than it priced for.

How audits catch it

Insurers and state fraud investigators have several ways of spotting misreported payroll:

  • Premium audits. Most workers’ comp policies are audited after the policy year, using payroll records, tax filings and bank statements. A big gap between reported payroll and actual payroll is the first red flag.
  • Subcontractor records. As in this case, investigators can subpoena the records of subcontractors and suppliers, which often show the real scale of a job.
  • Money trails. Cashing large volumes of payroll checks through money service businesses, rather than paying workers through traceable payroll, is a classic concealment pattern.
  • Certificates of insurance. A minimal policy can be used to present a certificate of insurance to clients or general contractors while the real workforce goes uninsured — a pattern Florida investigators have seen in larger organised schemes too.
  • Classification checks. Even honest mistakes — reporting workers under the wrong, cheaper job classification — get picked up in audit.

The consequences go well beyond a back-dated bill. In Florida, workers’ comp fraud can bring criminal charges, as this case shows, plus fines, repayment of the unpaid premium, and difficulty getting cover in the future.

What honest contractors should do at renewal

If you run a small contracting business, this case is a useful checklist rather than a cautionary tale about someone else. A few habits protect you:

  1. Report payroll accurately and completely. Include all employees, including part-timers and temporary workers, and update your insurer when headcount changes mid-year. It is far cheaper than an audit adjustment plus penalties.
  2. Keep payroll records clean and separate. Pay workers through traceable payroll, not cash or money service businesses. If an auditor ever asks, a clear paper trail is your best defence.
  3. Classify workers correctly. If your crew does roofing, framing and general labour, say so. Misclassification — even accidental — is one of the most common audit findings.
  4. Tell your insurer about subcontractors. If you use subs, confirm they carry their own workers’ comp. If they do not, their payroll can be added to yours at audit.
  5. Expect the audit, and prepare for it. Gather payroll records, tax returns and certificates of insurance before the auditor calls. A smooth audit usually means a smaller adjustment.
  6. Ask for a payroll audit review if the numbers look wrong. If an audit produces a surprise bill, ask your insurer or broker to walk through the calculation — mistakes do happen, and they can be corrected.

Why this matters beyond one case

Premium fraud is not a victimless shortcut. When one contractor pays $9,297 for cover that should have cost $109,863, the insurer absorbs the loss — and honest contractors pay for it through higher rates. It also leaves workers exposed: if someone is hurt on a job that was never properly reported, the claim, the coverage dispute and the legal fallout land on everyone involved.

For small contractors, the takeaway is simple. Accurate payroll reporting is not just a compliance chore — it is what keeps your cover real, your audits boring, and your business insurable at renewal.

Get a quote: Workers’ comp is priced on your real payroll, so an accurate quote starts with accurate numbers. Compare business insurance quotes online for your trade and see what proper cover costs. See our guide to how much workers’ compensation insurance costs (/how-much-is-workers-compensation-insurance/) and our small business insurance quotes (/small-business-insurance-quotes/) page to start.

Leave a Comment