If your employment practices liability premium went up at renewal, it was not your imagination. The EPL market is hardening — claims are more frequent, more complex, and more expensive to defend — and carriers are repricing to match.
That is the picture in a new E-Risk report, a Nationwide company, covered by Risk & Insurance on 21 November. For a small business owner with employees, it is the cover that pays when a worker alleges wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, or a wage-and-hour violation. And right now, every force behind those claims is pushing the same way: up.
A record year for enforcement
The numbers behind the hardening are stark. The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission recovered a record-breaking $528 million through pre-litigation enforcement alone in 2025 — the highest amount in the agency’s 60-year history, and 12% higher than fiscal year 2024. The EEOC also logged 88,201 new charges filed and 90,743 resolved charges during that period.
Large jury verdicts and high-profile coverage compound the pressure. Publicised outcomes become benchmarks that drive up settlement demands, and claimants point to them as the going rate.
What is driving the claims
Rapidly changing workplace conditions, expanding employee protections and new AI-driven risks are reshaping the exposure. The main drivers:
- New and expanding regulation. Federal statutes such as the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act keep creating new claim bases that many employers are not prepared for. Compliance with the Family Medical Leave Act and reasonable accommodation requirements is growing more complex as emotional and mental health disabilities enter the conversation.
- State laws add another layer. Pay transparency and equal pay laws are creating fresh litigation pressure, and employers with remote workforces may face very different exposures depending on where their employees happen to be sitting.
- Shifting enforcement priorities. Heightened scrutiny from the DOJ, DOL and EEOC around matters tied to religion, national origin, DEI, gender and pregnancy. Claim activity is expected to follow those priorities closely.
- AI on both sides of the claim. Regulators are actively testing the compliance risks when employers use AI in hiring and performance management. On the other side, claimants representing themselves are using AI to draft complaints and demand letters, dramatically lowering the cost and effort required to file. As E-Risk puts it, AI-generated demand letters are now being sent at low cost with minimal effort as a way to test whether companies will settle before a formal claim is filed.
- Workplace change itself. Hybrid and remote arrangements, return-to-office mandates and evolving DEI practices can create inconsistency — or at least the perception of unfairness — that fuels disputes.
E-Risk’s list of top anticipated claim sources reads like a checklist for any employer: wage, hour and leave issues; breach of employment contract; AI use in HR processes; harassment and discrimination; and DEI practices.
Why premiums are rising
All of this is driving a repricing of concentrated risk. As E-Risk notes, without pricing that reflects these new realities, carriers will be left with underpriced policies that contribute to higher loss ratios — and if the market does not correct itself with the higher pricing needed to cover current risks, carriers will begin to lose interest and appetite.
In plain terms: the cover is getting more expensive because the claims behind it are getting more frequent and more costly to defend. And carriers that enter the market with undisciplined underwriting often exit just as quickly when the line stops being profitable — so chasing the cheapest quote in a hardening market can leave you with a carrier that is not there when you need it.
What to check before you renew
E-Risk’s guidance for brokers doubles as a checklist for employers. Before your next renewal, review:
- Are your limits and retentions still right for your headcount and venue? A business that has grown, added remote staff in new states, or moved into a plaintiff-friendly venue may be underinsured on limits it set years ago.
- Have wage-and-hour exposures and sublimits been reviewed? Wage, hour and leave issues are now a top claim source. Check whether your policy’s wage-and-hour sublimit — if it has one — matches the exposure.
- Is third-party coverage in place? If your business interacts with the public — customers, clients, vendors — third-party EPLI covers claims from non-employees. Many small businesses do not carry it.
- Are your handbooks, accommodation processes and manager training current and documented? Documentation is often the difference between a claim that can easily be defended and one that becomes costly. Carriers reward employers with a mature risk management structure: updated employee handbooks, regular management training, and detailed records of hiring, performance, discipline and termination decisions.
- Does your carrier handle claims well? Claims tactics are changing. Carriers that respond quickly to demand letters can prevent escalation and keep defence costs lower than if a demand letter turns into a formal complaint. E-Risk advises employers to look for EPL partners with high-quality, efficient claims handling and a carrier that can help craft a strategic response at the demand-letter stage.
The bottom line
The changes driving claim frequency and complexity are not going anywhere. Workplace conditions will remain unpredictable, federal enforcement priorities will keep shifting, and AI will continue lowering the barrier to filing claims. In a hardening market, the right move is not to drop the cover or chase the cheapest premium — it is to make sure the limits, sublimits and carrier behind your EPLI match the business you actually run, and that your documentation can defend it.
If you employ people, EPLI is no longer a nice-to-have. Get a quote, check the exclusions, and compare the claims service — not just the price.
Source: E-Risk (Nationwide) report via Risk & Insurance, 21 Nov 2026; EEOC record enforcement figures via EEOC, 6 Apr 2026.
He is a dedicated Business Insurance Specialist and the founder of BusinessInsuranceTalk.com. With years of experience in risk management, he simplifies complex policies like General Liability and Professional Indemnity to help US small business owners secure affordable, high-quality coverage.