New Jersey lawmakers have taken the first formal step toward banning artificial intelligence from denying insurance claims on its own. The Assembly Science, Innovation and Technology Committee advanced a bill that would prohibit certain uses of AI in denying homeowners, automobile and flood insurance claims — and require a human in the loop when a major decision affects someone’s life.
The bill, A5494, advanced with only Assemblyman Chris DePhillips (R-Wyckoff) abstaining; every other committee member voted in favour. A second bill, A5495, regulating automated tenant screening systems, advanced on the same vote pattern. A third proposal, A4981, which would regulate AI-based electronic monitoring of employees, received a discussion-only hearing.
What the bill would do
A5494 targets a specific practice: an algorithm deciding, without human review, that a claim should be denied. Committee chairman Assemblyman Chris Tully (D-Bergenfield) framed it as a guardrail, not a ban on the technology itself.
“While AI systems can improve efficiency and tackle fraud, we must protect people from automatic denial by algorithms. When a major decision affects someone’s life, there must always be a human in the loop,” Tully said. “By mandating human oversight for these critical systems, we are establishing the common-sense guardrails necessary to use these powerful tools responsibly.”
Assemblywoman Carmen Morales (D-Bloomfield) defended the proposal as a consumer protection measure, calling it “really about transparency”.
Why insurers and business groups object
Industry representatives told the committee the restrictions could limit their ability to use new technology and leave companies at a competitive disadvantage. Business groups went further, warning of substantial costs and arguing the bill’s definition of artificial intelligence is too broad — potentially sweeping ordinary business tools into new regulation.
Anthony Russo of the Commerce and Industry Association of New Jersey said the proposal would “add a high cost to companies that invent those technologies”, while Jack Ramirez of the New Jersey Business and Industry Association warned that “businesses are going to be left guessing about what technologies and tools are actually subject to these requirements”.
The workplace-monitoring bill drew a similar split. Labour representatives argued employers should face restrictions on using AI to monitor workers, with Eric Richards of the New Jersey AFL-CIO saying the technology “has the power to change the very nature of work as we know it”. Business groups countered that the requirements could impose substantial costs and leave employers uncertain about which technologies are covered.
What this means for small business owners
Two honest caveats first. These bills have cleared a committee, not the full Legislature — they are not law yet. And A5494 as described covers homeowners, automobile and flood claims, not commercial lines. But the direction of travel matters for any business that buys insurance, for three reasons:
- Claims are where AI meets your business first. Carriers already use AI across underwriting, fraud detection and claims triage. A rule requiring human review of AI-driven denials in personal lines is the template regulators reach for next in commercial lines. If you have ever had a claim delayed or denied, ask your carrier or broker whether AI played a role in the decision — and who reviewed it.
- Your own AI use is in scope too. The workplace-monitoring bill (A4981) would regulate AI-based electronic monitoring of employees. If you use productivity monitoring, AI screening tools or automated HR systems, the compliance questions New Jersey is asking now are the ones other states will ask next. Keep records of what your tools decide and who checks them.
- Regulation follows the money. The same committee also advanced data-centre transparency bills (A5224, and S4304/A2774, which would prohibit non-disclosure agreements concealing data-centre developments). When lawmakers regulate the infrastructure behind AI in the same session as AI in insurance, the regulatory trend is unmistakable: expect more rules, not fewer, on how AI is used in decisions that affect people and businesses.
For now, the practical move is simple: at renewal, ask your broker how your carrier uses AI in claims handling, and whether a human reviews AI-flagged denials. The answer is becoming part of what good cover looks like.
Source: New Jersey Globe, 17 November 2026 — https://newjerseyglobe.com/legislature/n-j-lawmakers-move-to-regulate-ai-in-insurance-housing-and-the-workplace/
Get a quote: Rules on AI in claims are changing fast, but the basics are not: the right cover, honestly described, with a carrier that pays claims fairly. Compare business insurance quotes online for your trade and see what proper cover costs. See our small business insurance quotes page to start.
He is a dedicated Business Insurance Specialist and the founder of BusinessInsuranceTalk.com. With years of experience in risk management, he simplifies complex policies like General Liability and Professional Indemnity to help US small business owners secure affordable, high-quality coverage.